Only 3 “ships” were mentioned in the “Passengers Arrived” above the “Marine Intelligence” report for “Port of New York, September 19, 1851”. 

Emily
“In brig, Emily, from Charleston-G. Whitman, Mary Jane, Ann, and Sarah Whitman, Charlotte R. Card, L. W. Martin, Cordelia Martin, and 10 in steerage.”

Find ancestors with an Ancestry US Free Trial, Ancestry Canada Free Trial, Ancestry.UK Free Trial or Ancestry Australia Free Trial