Only 3 “ships” were mentioned in the “Passengers Arrived” above the “Marine Intelligence” report for “Port of New York, September 19, 1851”. 

John Colby
“In bark, John Colby, from Ponce, P. R.-John W. Labam and servant, Adolphus Porretta, Joseph de Leon, Mrs. Emeline Reguera, Masters Fred. [short for Frederick?], Reguera, Francis Reguera, Alfred Fredrick Mena.”

Find ancestors with an Ancestry US Free Trial, Ancestry Canada Free Trial, Ancestry.UK Free Trial or Ancestry Australia Free Trial